What Happened with D:CODE Sri Nakarin and Why It Concerns All Buyers
At the end of 2024, Bangkok was hit by a scandal surrounding the D:CODE Sri Nakarin project by developer Sena Development. Dozens of foreign buyers who had paid deposits and signed Sale and Purchase Agreements (SPA) were unable to register their units at the Land Office. The reason: the 49% foreign quota was exhausted before the developer began transferring ownership rights. Some buyers were denied registration despite having executed contracts and transferred money from abroad with a Foreign Exchange Transaction (FET) form. The situation revealed a systemic problem: the lack of a transparent mechanism for allocating the foreign quota among buyers within a single building.
{photo:hero}
According to the Phuket Real Estate Association, up to 8% of transactions involving foreigners in 2024-2025 were accompanied by legal issues, with a significant portion related specifically to quotas. For buyers in Pattaya, where foreigners account for up to 60% of condominium demand, understanding quota mechanics has become not just a matter of legal literacy, but of protecting their money.
How the Foreign Quota Works by Law: Basic Rules
According to the Condominium Act B.E. 2522 (1979) as amended in 2008, foreign nationals may own condominiums in Thailand in freehold format, but only within established limits. The foreign quota is a maximum of 49% of the total area of all sellable units in a single building. The remaining 51% must be registered to Thai citizens or Thai legal entities.
It's important to understand: the quota is calculated by area, not by number of units. If a condominium has a total unit area of 10,000 m², no more than 4,900 m² is available to foreigners. This means one large 200 m² penthouse "consumes" as much quota as eight 25 m² studios.
Two conditions are mandatory for registering ownership rights to a foreigner at the Land Office:
- Funds for the purchase were transferred from abroad in foreign currency (USD, EUR, etc.), confirmed by an FET form from a Thai bank.
- At the time of registration, sufficient foreign quota remains in the building to cover the area of the unit being purchased.
If even one condition is not met, registration is impossible. The buyer will be denied, even if the Sale and Purchase Agreement is signed and money is paid in full.
The Allocation Problem: Who Gets Quota First
The law clearly establishes the 49% limit but does not regulate the order of distributing this quota among buyers. In practice, the developer independently decides which foreign buyers receive quota allocation and which are denied. No official priority registry exists. This creates grounds for abuse and conflicts.
In the D:CODE Sri Nakarin case, the developer sold more units to foreigners than the quota allowed. When registration at the Land Office began, it became clear that the quota was exhausted. Some buyers who signed SPAs later than others but paid deposits earlier were left out. Others, conversely, managed to register rights, although their contracts were concluded later.
The reason: the developer did not maintain transparent quota allocation records and did not record buyer priority. Decisions were made situationally, often favoring those who submitted documents to the Land Office faster or had connections with the sales department.
{photo:mid}
Three Scenarios When Quota Runs Out Early
Scenario 1: Double Booking
The developer sells the same unit twice-first to a foreigner, then to a Thai. The foreign buyer pays a deposit, signs the SPA, but registration is postponed for several months (for example, until construction completion). During this time, the developer resells the apartment to a Thai buyer, citing "technical problems" with the first contract. The foreign quota is formally not spent, but the buyer loses the unit.
In Pattaya, such cases have been recorded in secondary market projects where the developer has already completed construction but some units remain unsold. Agents resell the same apartments to different clients, counting on the fact that not everyone will reach the registration stage.
Scenario 2: Selling Above Quota Without Warning
The developer sells 55-60% of the building's area to foreigners, although the quota only allows 49%. Buyers are not informed that the quota is exhausted. The SPA states "freehold ownership" but without specifying "foreign freehold" and without indicating quota verification. When registration time comes, some buyers receive an offer to register leasehold (long-term lease for 30 years) instead of freehold or register the unit through a Thai company.
This scenario is typical for small developers in Pattaya who do not have a legal department and rely on agents. Agents are interested in quick sales and do not check remaining quota before signing the SPA.
Scenario 3: Changing Unit Status After Sale
The developer sells units to foreigners within the quota but then transfers some of them to the Thai quota at the request of other buyers or investors. For example, a major Thai investor wants to buy several penthouses that were initially reserved for foreigners. The developer accommodates, freeing up foreign quota at the expense of already sold units. Foreign buyers only learn about this at the registration stage.
In Pattaya, such manipulations occur in premium projects where Thai buyers are willing to pay more for specific units with sea views or on high floors.
How to Check Quota Before Signing a Contract: Checklist
Step 1: Request a Foreigner Quota Report
This is an official document showing the current status of the foreign quota in the building. It indicates:
- Total area of all units in the condominium (m²)
- Area already registered to foreigners (m²)
- Remaining available quota (m²)
- List of units reserved for foreigners but not yet registered
The document is issued by the condominium management company (juristic office) or the developer itself if the building has not yet been handed over. Request a report no older than 7 days-quota can change quickly.
Step 2: Check the Wording in the SPA
The Sale and Purchase Agreement must clearly state: "Foreign Freehold ownership within the 49% foreign quota, subject to availability at the time of transfer." If it simply states "freehold" without mentioning quota-this is a red flag. The developer is leaving itself a loophole for denial.
Demand inclusion in the SPA of a clause: "The Seller guarantees that the Unit is allocated within the foreign quota and will be registered as foreign freehold at the Land Office. If the foreign quota is exhausted, the Buyer has the right to cancel the contract and receive a full refund of all payments, including the deposit."
Step 3: Check the Building's Chanote
Chanote (Nor Sor 4) is the primary title deed document for land. It should indicate that a condominium has been erected on the plot and the building is registered at the Land Office. If the Chanote is issued to an individual (for example, to the developer's owner) rather than to the project's legal entity, this is a sign that the developer may not have full rights to manage the quota.
Also check whether there are any encumbrances on the Chanote: mortgages in favor of a bank, court seizures, pledges. If the land is pledged, the bank may impose a ban on registering new ownership rights until the debt is paid.
Step 4: Clarify Registration Priority
Ask the developer in what order unit registration at the Land Office will proceed. If the developer cannot give a clear answer or says "all simultaneously," this is cause for concern. Registration always proceeds sequentially: first one unit, then the next. Find out what number in line your unit has.
If the developer offers to expedite registration for an additional fee-decline. This is a sign that quota is being distributed non-transparently, and your money may simply go toward bribing an official or agent.
What to Do If Quota Is Exhausted: Three Legal Options
Option 1: 30-Year Leasehold
If the foreign quota is exhausted, the buyer can register the unit under long-term lease (leasehold) for 30 years with the possibility of two more 30-year extensions (up to 90 years total). The developer or Thai legal entity remains the owner, while the foreigner receives the right of use.
Advantages: legally clean format, does not require FET, can be rented out and the remaining use period can be sold.
Disadvantages: lease does not provide voting rights at condominium owner meetings, extension after 30 years is not guaranteed by law (depends on owner consent), when selling, leasehold value is 20-30% lower than freehold.
Option 2: Purchase Through a Thai Company
The foreigner registers a Thai Limited Company in which Thais own 51% of shares and the foreigner owns 49%. The company purchases a unit in the Thai quota in freehold format. The foreigner controls the company through preferred shares, which provide the right to a majority of votes in decision-making.
Advantages: full freehold ownership, can buy a villa or house with land (not just a condominium).
Disadvantages: requires annual reporting to the Revenue Department and maintaining minimum registered capital (usually 1 million baht), falls under the Foreign Business Act (the company must not conduct commercial activities without a BOI license), Thai shareholders must be real people with their own funds (using nominee shareholders is illegal and can lead to transaction cancellation).
Option 3: Canceling the Deal and Refund
If the SPA includes a condition guaranteeing foreign quota, the buyer has the right to terminate the contract and demand full refund of all amounts paid, including the deposit. The developer is obligated to return the money within 30-60 days (the period is specified in the contract).
If the developer refuses to return the money, the buyer can file a lawsuit in the Civil Court of Thailand. The consideration period is 6 to 18 months. For foreigners, engaging a Thai lawyer is mandatory, as all documents must be in Thai language.
What This Means for Buyers in Pattaya
Pattaya remains one of the most popular destinations for condominium purchases among foreigners. According to CBRE Thailand, in 2024 foreigners purchased about 4,200 condominium units in Pattaya, representing approximately 58% of total sales. Demand from Russians, Kazakhs, and Ukrainians increased by 22% compared to 2023.
High demand creates pressure on the foreign quota. In popular beachfront projects (Wongamat, Pratumnak, Jomtien), the 49% quota fills up during pre-sales, 12-18 months before construction completion. Buyers who enter the market later risk being left without freehold.
Example: in The Riviera Wongamat Beach project by Riviera Group developer, the foreign quota was exhausted 8 months before building handover. Buyers who signed SPAs in the last 4 months before transfer received offers to register leasehold or transfer their deposit to another project by the same group. About 15% declined and demanded refunds, which took 3 to 6 months.
To minimize risks when buying in Pattaya, it is recommended to:
- Work only with developers who publish current Foreigner Quota Reports on their website or provide them upon request within 24 hours.
- Include in the SPA a clause guaranteeing quota with the right to cancel and refund.
- Check the building's Chanote through an independent lawyer before paying the deposit.
- Avoid projects where the developer offers to "reserve quota" for an additional fee-this is a sign of non-transparent management.
- When buying in the secondary market, request a copy of the Foreigner Quota Report no older than 7 days and verify that the unit is actually registered in the foreign quota (this is visible in the Land Office extract).
The D:CODE Sri Nakarin scandal showed that even major developers do not always maintain transparency in quota distribution. In Pattaya, where the market is less regulated and there are more small developers, risks are higher. Checking quota before signing the SPA is not a formality but a mandatory step that can save the buyer from 2 to 10 million baht and several months of stress.
Conclusions: Pre-Purchase Checklist
Buying a condominium in Pattaya with freehold rights requires not only money and an FET form, but also understanding foreign quota mechanics. The law establishes a 49% limit but does not regulate the order of distributing this quota among buyers. The developer can sell more units than the quota allows, and some buyers will be left without ownership rights.
Before signing the SPA, check:
- Foreigner Quota Report-remaining available quota in the building
- Wording in the SPA-it should state "Foreign Freehold within 49% quota"
- Building's Chanote-absence of encumbrances and pledges
- Registration priority-your number in the Land Office registration list
- Refund conditions-if quota is exhausted before registration
If quota is exhausted, legal alternatives are 30-year leasehold or purchase through a Thai company. Both options have limitations and require additional costs. Canceling the deal with a refund is only possible if the SPA includes a quota guarantee.
Working with a verified developer and independent lawyer reduces risks but does not eliminate them completely. The Pattaya market is dynamic, demand from foreigners is high, and quotas fill up quickly. A buyer who understands quota mechanics and checks documents at every stage obtains freehold without problems. Those who rely on agent promises risk being left with leasehold or losing their deposit.
